Donald Trump deportation plan

If elected, Donald Trump's mass deportation plan could affect 11 million undocumented immigrants by suspending humanitarian programs and ramping up enforcement. This controversial Donald Trump deportation plan may enco...

David Aman

10/30/20242 min read

a group of people holding signs
a group of people holding signs

If Donald Trump wins the 2024 election, his proposed immigration policy includes sweeping measures that could dramatically reshape U.S. immigration. Trump's plan centers on mass deportation of undocumented immigrants, estimated at about 11 million people. To achieve this, he would need an unprecedented expansion of the current detention and deportation infrastructure, including building new facilities and significantly increasing immigration enforcement staff. Experts suggest this effort could cost hundreds of billions, potentially requiring hundreds of thousands of new personnel to handle enforcement and detention processes, with private detention companies expected to benefit from new contracts.

Additionally, Trump has proposed to end various humanitarian programs, such as Temporary Protected Status (TPS), Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA), and certain humanitarian parole programs. This action would revoke the protected status of around 1.4 million people, many of whom have lived in the U.S. for years. He also intends to suspend refugee admissions entirely, building on his previous cuts to refugee caps during his presidency. This complete suspension could face resistance as it goes against international and humanitarian commitments.

A legally controversial part of Trump’s approach involves invoking the Alien Enemies Act of 1798 to target gang members and cartel affiliates. This act, historically used during wartime, would allow the president to deport groups without due process if they’re from countries deemed hostile. However, legal experts indicate that using this for immigration enforcement would face significant legal challenges.

Local law enforcement agencies may also play a role, as Trump intends to mobilize them along with the National Guard to carry out deportations. However, several law enforcement leaders have expressed reservations or outright refusal to participate, citing concerns over local resources and community trust.

Beyond the direct costs, Trump's plan could have economic implications, particularly in sectors where immigrants form a substantial portion of the labor force. Analysts warn that mass deportation could shrink the U.S. workforce and even impact GDP significantly, comparable to recessionary conditions in recent history, as immigrants often work in sectors where there is already a shortage of labor.

Overall, if enacted, Trump’s mass deportation plan would likely face substantial legal, logistical, and financial hurdles, with profound effects on both the immigrant community and broader U.S. society.

What to Expect If He Wins the Election